Hegel, the Modern Liberal and its Consequences

Contact Your Elected Officials

Like oil and water, freedom and dependency are immiscibleโ€“they don’t mix.

In a previous post of mine entitled, โ€œIs Man the Measure?โ€ the distinction between Classical and Modern Liberalism was elaborated. The idea in classical liberalism is that natural rights are endowed as human freedom and justified through an appeal to that which is the basis for why there is something rather than nothing–for why the universe is rather than is not–and this without recourse to any human or human institution.

Modern liberalism begins and ends with the self and what it believes it needs. Rather than individual rights being endowed by that which is unchanging, the natural law, it centers its source of freedom in the vicissitudes of human needs and desire for self-referentiality and absolute autonomy.

This essay describes how modern liberalism fosters a false sense of need in various populations in America. It then goes further to illustrate how the above leads to a type of โ€œmaster-slaveโ€ relationship, promoting dependency by these groups upon the state.

So what do Hegel and modern liberals have in common? They each believe the state is best at addressing your needs and desires while ostensibly making you free.

Nineteenth century German philosopher, George Friedrich Hegel, was adamant in his view of the state as being superior to the individual:

โ€œThe state is the absolute reality and the individual himself has objective existence, truth and morality only in his capacity as a member of the state.โ€

A university professor at Jena and Berlin, Hegel believed that freedoms and rights come from the state, and that individuals are subordinate to the dictates of the state.

In his โ€œMaster-Slave dialecticโ€ (meaning relationship) Hegel in his The Phenomenology of Spirit, introduces the idea that one’s true identity is a product of society and culture, and that it cannot be achieved through individual existenceโ€“relationship with an โ€œotherโ€ is needed.

The modern liberal

Hegelโ€™s views can tell us something about the thought of modern liberalsโ€“how they see freedom and dependency, themselves and others in the world. They both agree that only by seeing ourselves in relation to other humans in society can we gain a sense of dignity and establish our place in the world. In other words we cannot do it by ourselvesโ€“modern liberals foster this image of the โ€œself-in-need of the other.โ€ They need others to fulfill who they understand themselves to be. The problem is that these liberals often view others as people in need of something from them. Through this continuous pattern of perception of need by the other, modern liberals fulfill their own need.ย They give while the other becomes dependent by accepting that which is given. A relationship is established.

What does this mean under the rubric of modern liberalism in America?

For decades, minority populations have played a role of โ€œdependencyโ€ in America, while modern liberals play that of โ€œmaintaining that dependency.โ€ As you will see, the relationship is, psychologically and sociologically, self-destructive for both. Kevin Martin, a member of the African-American leadership network Project 21, writing for The National Center for Public Policy Research (2006) comments:

โ€œLiberalism is not just a problem for black America. Its failure can be seen by visiting any Martin Luther King Street, Avenue, or Boulevard. White America has the financial wherewithal and ambition to choose to escape it. Black Americans, due to long-term abuse by liberal policies, donโ€™t always have that option. Thatโ€™s why black America as a whole needs to wake up and shake off the liberal chains that bind us.โ€

Modern liberals of the majority race have since the 1960s tended to view minority politics through the โ€œlensโ€ of a dependency relationship. They have viewed Americans of African descent as well as the Hispanic community as being needy, requiring continuing social, economic and political assistance from themโ€“from the state.

This orientation has persisted in America for 60 years. And for much of that time, let’s be clear, government assistance was not only helpful but necessary to redress decades of inequality. Today, however, increasing numbers of the minority population, itself, are advocating for modern liberalism to foster its role in the minds of that populationโ€“that they still need liberals to sustain themselves. Such โ€œreasoningโ€ is not only counterproductive to minorities in America, it is disrespectful. Moreover, this dependency relationship is fostered, today, by modern liberals for a more invidious reason–political power through the ballot. It has become about the numbers, not the needs of the minorities. The latter’s embrace of dependency needs to be maintained, so as to foster continued political power for liberals.

In a January 2024 article in TIME, Congressional Democrats announced that โ€œthey will invest at least $35 million to reach voters of color in the 2024 election cycleโ€ฆa historic investment, superseding the $30 million spent on attracting minority voters from Latino, Black, Asian, and Pacific Islander/Native Hawaiian communities in the 2022 midterm elections.โ€ The article goes on to say that โ€œvoters of color have long been pivotal to Democratic election prospects. About 73% of Asian, Black, and Latino voters combined backed President Joe Biden in 2020.โ€

Finally, some modern liberals promote this dependency to satisfy their own need to atone for and redress perceived past transgressions (real or otherwise). Guilt, driven by socioeconomic disparity and history, can be a powerful motivator, indeed. It becomes their raison d’etre. In a subsequent essay I will explore the consequences of these relationships as they relate to their potential effects on America’s future.

The psychology of this relationship does a disservice to the intellect of minority populations in America. Providing assistance when necessary, in and of itself, is not the problem; rather, it’s the condescending attitude of modern liberals toward these populations as being incapable of caring for themselves without liberal handouts as well as the need for the group to continue its relationship of dependency.

According to a 2018 study by Cydney Dupree, assistant professor of organizational behavior at Yale School of Management, โ€œwhite liberals tend to downplay their own verbal competence in exchanges with racial minorities, compared to how other white Americans act in such exchanges.โ€ The study was published in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology.

This reciprocal relationship of condescension-dependency perpetuates a dependency mentality which is, I submit, toxic to American society.

To free oneself of one’s voluntary servitude to another, one must recognize that one’s freedom and natural rights are inherent in one’s human being. Such natural freedom cannot be granted to you by a state, they are fundamental. But liberty can be taken from you through positive rights or laws from a state. The decision is ours to make–either master of our own consciousness or a slave to another’s.

As is evident from the above, granting positive rights to one group without due consideration for the rights of others can get rather messy and remains controversial. What we see in modern liberalism is the state granting rights which often do damage to society. After realizing, but not always acknowledging, the damage done, it tries to rectify its transgressions by imposing a new set of rights to counter the old. It becomes a circular process that seemingly never ends. At least it hasn’t yet.

Force Man to be Free

Positive rights, of course, can be a form of freedom when careful consideration is accorded the consequences of such acts.ย Problems develop when the state is used to further an agenda to impose upon one the right (meaning the necessity) to receive something or act in some particular way. When additional rights are granted to some (e.g. affirmative action), others lose aspects of their freedom (reverse discrimination). It isn’t that the former is necessarily wrong; it’s just that the latter is absolutely wrong.

As is often the case with modern liberalism, what starts out as a good idea for some in America results in adverse effects through ill-considered consequences and diminished rights for others. Between modern liberalismโ€™s propensity for dependency-driven relationships and granting positive rights to foster political power, should we not be concerned about the status of freedom in America?

Eighteenth century French philosopher Jean-Jacque Rousseau once claimed in The Social Contract, that we must “force man to be free,” such that he might “place all his power in common under the supreme direction of the general will” of the state. Sound familiar? That is a scary thoughtโ€“it’s also kin to modern liberalism.

F. Andrew Wolf, Jr.
F. Andrew Wolf, Jr.
F. Andrew Wolf, Jr. is a retired USAF Lt. Col. and retired university professor of the Humanities, Philosophy of Religion and Philosophy. His education includes a PhD in philosophy from Univ. of Wales, two masters degrees (MTh-Texas Christian Univ.), (MA-Univ. South Africa) and an abiding passion for what is in America's best interest.

Liberal Democrat Content Creators are Despicable Defamationers

What should Christian conservatives do when confronted with false information to the point of bearing false witness against someone like President Trump?

Ben Shapiro Warning Me Not to Listen to InfoWars Makes Me Want to Listen 10x Harder

This rant from Ben Shapiro reveals more about him and his low opinion of his audience to whom he peddles his slop than it does about its target, Alex Jones.

Epsteinโ€™s Aftermath: Planes, Blames, and Autocrats

There are so many real, honest great journalists reporting the news on the internet these days that some really good content gets overlooked.

Why the Trump Administration is Sitting on the Epstein Files

President Trump, AG Bondi, and FBI Dir. Patel have the advantage over us in that they see the big overall picture when it comes to the Epstein List.

Trumpโ€™s โ€œMajor Statementโ€ On Russia Is A Clumsy Attempt To Thread The Needle

The โ€œmajor statementโ€ on Russia Trump hyped up turned out to be an attempt to thread the needle between escalating US involvement in Ukrainian and walking away from it.

7.3 Magnitude Earthquake Hits Off Alaska Coast; Tsunami Warning Issued

A 7.3-magnitude earthquake struck off the coast of southern Alaska prompting federal officials to issue a tsunami warning.

University of Southern California Faces $300 Million in Federal Funding Cuts, Staff Layoffs

USC faces potential revenue loss of hundreds of millions of dollars in federal funds and staff layoffs, amid "volatile external environment,โ€ Interim President says.

Florida AG Threatens Lawsuit Against US Masters Swimming Over Male Participation in Female Events

FL AG James Uthmeier, in a letter to CEO of U.S. Masters Swimming, called for immediate end to male athletes participating in female competitions by organization.

The Marketโ€™s Focus Returns to Tariffs

Surging tariff revenue is expected to help the Treasury Department better manage the federal government budget deficit.

EUโ€™s Trade Chief to Meet With US Officials as EU Braces for Tariff Showdown

The EUโ€™s trade leader is headed to Washington for face-to-face negotiations with the Trump admin, a spokesman for the economic bloc said.

Nvidiaโ€™s AI Chip Sales to China Tied to Rare Earths Trade Talks, Says Commerce Secretary

USsโ€™ decision to allow Nvidia to resume selling China AI chips is tied to recent trade negotiations over rare-earth exports, according to Sec Lutnick.

Trump Says USโ€“Vietnam Trade Deal Nearly Complete

President Trump said the trade deal between the United States and Vietnam was nearly complete, the same day he announced a new deal with Indonesia.

Washington Announces Investigation Into Brazilian Trade Practices, Digital Payment Services

U.S. Trade Representative Jamieson Greer announced the opening of an investigation into Brazilโ€™s โ€œunfairโ€ trading practices on July 15, 2025.
spot_img

Related Articles