All Supreme Court Justices Agree to Vacate Abortion Ruling Except One

The Epoch Times Header

Supreme Court Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson was the only dissenter in a high court decision that vacated a lower court ruling earlier this week allowing minors the right to go to court to get permission to seek an abortion.

The top U.S. court overturned a ruling issued by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit and remanded the case to the court with instructions to dismiss. The appeals court ruling in April (pdf) said a state court clerk could face a lawsuit for telling a pregnant teenager that the court must inform her parents of her bid to obtain a court order to receive an abortion without her parents’ approval.

In its order Monday (pdf), the Supreme Court issued no opinion or explanation for why. No other justice issued any objection to the high court’s action, which was announced as part of its routine slate of orders that were handed down.

But Jackson wrote a four-page dissent that argued justices have been too accepting in granting requests from parties who seek to nullify rulings from lower courts. She criticized the Supreme Court’s use of Munsingwear vacatur, a legal doctrine that is sometimes used to clear away lower court decisions.

The Munsingwear doctrine allows appeals courts, including the Supreme Court, to erase a precedent if it becomes moot while a losing party is appealing the decision and a higher court is reviewing the case.

“I am concerned that contemporary practice related to so called ‘Munsingwear vacaturs’ has drifted away from the doctrine’s foundational moorings,” Jackson wrote Monday.

In the case, Jane Doe, a pregnant minor, visited a local Missouri courthouse to apply for a dispensation allowing her to not receive consent from her parents for an abortion. But the office of the petitioner, Michelle Chapman—a clerk for Randolph County—told Doe that she couldn’t do so without notifying a parent.

Ultimately, Doe got an abortion in Illinois after a court in the state authorized it without her parents’ knowledge. She later filed a civil rights lawsuit in federal district court targeting Chapman and claimed the clerk violated her 14th Amendment rights, although Chapman argued that she was immune to lawsuits because she followed a Missouri statute and a judge’s directions.

By Jack Phillips

Read Full Article on TheEpochTimes.com

The Epoch Times
The Epoch Timeshttps://www.theepochtimes.com/
Tired of biased news? The Epoch Times is truthful, factual news that other media outlets don't report. No spin. No agenda. Just honest journalism like it used to be.

Columns

Biden’s Autopen Was A Mighty Big Sword

The autopen was used to sign Biden's name on pardons and EO, even when he was out of the country. Did he know what was signed? Did he authorize the signatures?

I Refuse To Be A Serf

“How are people not furious about property taxes?” President Trump...

Putting it to rest

As the nation hits its taxation stride on its way to April 15th and DOGE continues to reveal waste and fraud, a review of the nation’s finances is overdue.

Lefty Activist Judges are Obstructing Trump’s Presidency

Activist judge’s ruling to block President Donald Trump from being able to execute his Constitutional Article 2 Powers pose a real “Constitutional crisis”.

France’s Next Quarterly Nuclear Drills Might Become Prestige-Building Exercises With Poland

Europe wonders what form Macron’s plans to extend his nuclear umbrella over the continent could take, considering risks entailed after Moscow’s negative reaction.

News

Pentagon Taps 2 Firms That Partner With Ukraine to Make Drone Prototypes

Two Ukrainian companies will help manufacture prototype drones for the Pentagon, as the United States seeks to rapidly scale its unmanned capabilities.

Dismantling of Education Department Is Underway, Drawing Legal Challenges

Trump has yet to issue an EO to eliminate the Dept of Education or work with Congress to do it, but the process of dismantling it is well underway.

NASA’s Starliner Astronauts Welcome New Crew to Space Station

One day after blasting off from the Kennedy Space Center in Florida, the SpaceX Crew-10 capsule arrived at the International Space Station on March 16.

Sen. Lankford Sees New ‘Wild Card’ Role as Chance to Speed Up Senate

Sen. James Lankford is guiding colleagues as vice chair of the Senate Republican Conference informing media and the public about efforts of party’s senators.

Massive Storm Leaves at Least 33 Dead as US Hit by Tornadoes, Wildfires, Blinding Dust

Violent weather broke out across the central and southern US, sending tornadoes and high winds with storm killing at least 33 people as of March 16.

Judge Blocks Trump’s Efforts to Deport Gang Members Under 1798 Alien Enemies Act

Federal judge blocked Trump’s efforts to rapidly deport members of Venezuelan gang Tren de Aragua through use of the Alien Enemies Act of 1798.

US to Pay El Salvador $6 Million to Imprison 300 Illegal Immigrant Gang Members for a Year

Trump admin is set to pay El Salvador $6 million to hold 300 members of Venezuelan Tren de Aragua gang and 2 alleged members of MS-13 in prison for a year.
spot_img

Related Articles

Popular Categories

MAGA Business Central