Overview
Even though Donald Trump is now the nationโs front-running presidential candidate in both polls and betting odds, the Colorado Supreme Court has issued a 4โ3 decision that bans the citizens of Colorado from voting for him. The supposed grounds for their decision is that Trump canโt be the president under the U.S. Constitutionโs 14th Amendment because he โengaged in insurrection on January 6, 2021.โ
To support that claim, the Colorado judgesโall appointed by Democratsโrepeatedly quote Trump out of context to make it seem like he said things that he did not.
โVery Different Rulesโ
In their decision, the majority of judges assert that Trump โtold his supportersโ on January 6th that โthey were โallowed to go by very different rulesโโ and that those words โwere intended to produce imminent lawless action.โ
The judges repeat the phrase โvery different rulesโ four different times, but they never reveal the words that immediately follow. These prove that Trump was not talking about his โsupporters,โ as the judges allege, but Mike Pence. Per the transcript of Trumpโs speech:
When you catch somebody in a fraud, youโre allowed to go by very different rules. So I hope Mike has the courage to do what he has to do.
Those words refer to Trumpโs call for Pence to send the electors โback to the States to recertify,โ as Trump said in the same speech.
The broader context also reveals that Trump was speaking about Congress, a point he raised four times in his speech. Thatโs because Congress was debating on that day whether the 2020 election was carried out in accord with the U.S. Constitution and whether the federal Electoral Count Act allowed Congress to object to โStates that did not follow the constitutional requirement for selecting electors.โ
Trumpโs statement was true at the time, as shown by the text of the Electoral Count Act, which specified very different rules for cases of potential fraud. However, Democrats, several Republicans, and President Biden changed this law in 2022 to remove certain checks against election fraud.
โFight Like Hellโ
Echoing the 2021 impeachment resolution of Trump, the Colorado judges claim that Trump โgave a speech in which he literally exhorted his supporters to fight at the Capitol.โ Their alleged proof of this is that Trump โused the word โfightโ or variations of itโ 20 times on January 6.
Yet, the judges only cite the following cases of Trump using the word โfight,โ none of which literally calls for violence:
- โRepublicans are constantly fighting like a boxer with his hands tied behind his back. Itโs like a boxer. And we want to be so nice. We want to be so respectful of everybody, including bad people. And weโre going to have to fight much harder.โ
- โAnd we fight. We fight like hell. And if you donโt fight like hell, youโre not going to have a country anymore.โ
Seemingly ignorant of the fact that the words โliteralโ and โcodedโ have opposing meanings, the judges claim that the statements above were โcoded languageโ that Trump used as โliteral calls to violence.โ
More importantly, the full record of Trumpโs remarks show that he was talking about legal and verbal fighting, not physical violence. Ten of the 20 times in which Trump used the word โfightโ are found in the following statements where the context is unmistakable:
- Rudy Giuliani has โguts, he fights. He fights.โ
- โJim Jordan, and some of these guys. Theyโre out there fighting the House.โ
- โIf they donโt fight, we have to primary the hell out of the ones that donโt fight. You primary them.โ
- โThe American people do not believe the corrupt fake news anymore. They have ruined their reputation. But it used to be that theyโd argue with me, Iโd fight. So Iโd fight, theyโd fight. Iโd fight, theyโd fight. โฆ They had their point of view, I had my point of view. But youโd have an argument. Now what they do is they go silent. Itโs called suppression. And thatโs what happens in a communist country.โ
Exposing the double standards of those who claim that Trumpโs use of the word โfightโ was a call for violence, video footage shows Congressional Democrats using the word โfightโ more than 200 times, including more than a dozen times in which they used the exact phrase for which they impeached Trump: โfight like hell.โ
โTo the Capitolโ
Another phrase that the Colorado judges focus on is โto the Capitol,โ which Trump used three times in his speech. The judges allege that these words were part of Trumpโs plot to engage โin an insurrectionโ by physically preventing โCongress from certifying the 2020 presidential election and stop the peaceful transfer of power.โ
In reality, the context shows the polar opposite is true. The first time Trump used the phrase โto the Capitol,โ he said:
We have come to demand that Congress do the right thing and only count the electors who have been lawfully slated, lawfully slated. I know that everyone here will soon be marching over to the Capitol building to peacefully and patriotically make your voices heard.
The judges bury the fact that Trump told his supporters to protest โpeacefully and patrioticallyโโ127 pages into their ruling. Then they dismiss this fact in two sentences by arguing that Trump told the crowd an hour later to โfight like hellโ just before he told them to go to the Capitol. Here again, the full context of Trumpโs words reveals no explicit or implicit calls for violence:
Weโre going walk down to the Capitol, and weโre going to cheer on our brave senators, and congressmen and women. Weโre probably not going to be cheering so much for some of them because youโll never take back our country with weakness. You have to show strength, and you have to be strong.
The same applies to Trumpโs other use of the phrase โto the Capitol,โ in which he called for a protest to sway the votes of โweakโ Republicans, not to stop the proceedings:
So weโre going to, weโre going to walk down Pennsylvania Avenue, I love Pennsylvania Avenue, and weโre going to the Capitol and weโre going to try and giveโthe Democrats are hopeless. Theyโre never voting for anything, not even one vote. But weโre going to try and give our Republicans, the weak ones, because the strong ones donโt need any of our help, weโre going to try and give them the kind of pride and boldness that they need to take back our country.
Conclusion
Near the end of their ruling, the Colorado Supreme Court adjudicates whether Trump intended to โproduce violent or lawless action.โ They then cram all of their out-of-context quotes into a single sentence which asserts that Trump urged his supporters to go โto the Capitol,โ โfight like hell,โ and go by โvery different rules.โ
In reality, the full context of Trumpโs words show that he told his supporters to:
- go โto the Capitolโ peacefully and patriotically.
- โfight like hellโ politically and verbally.
- encourage Mike Pence and Congress to follow the โvery different rulesโ that federal law specified for cases of potential election fraud.
James D. Agresti is the president of Just Facts, a research institute dedicated to publishing facts about public policies and teaching research skills.