Critical Race Theory Would Not Solve Racial Inequality: It Would Deepen It

The Heritage Foundation

 SUMMARY

Critical race theory is an ideology which maintains that the United States is a fundamentally racist country and that American institutions such as the Constitution, property rights, color blindness, and equal protection under the law are vestiges of white supremacy, patriarchy, and capitalist oppressionโ€”all of which must be overthrown in the name of โ€œantiracism.โ€ Ultimately, critical race theory and โ€œantiracismโ€ policies would deepen racial divisions and undermine the very institutions that are essential to addressing poverty and inequality across all racial groups. Policymakers concerned about these issues should reject critical race theory and orient public policy toward rebuilding the institutions of family, work, and education, which have been proven to lift Americans of all racial backgrounds out of poverty.

KEY TAKEAWAYS

  1. Critical race theorists falsely accuse the United States of being a fundamentally racist nation and condemns capitalism, individual rights, and the Constitution.
  2. Critical race theory ignores evidence that shows that family structure, educational attainment, and workforce participation are the primary drivers of inequality.
  3. Critical race theory seeks to undermine the foundations of American society and replace the constitutional system with a near-totalitarian โ€œantiracistโ€ bureaucracy.

Critical race theory has emerged as one of the most influentialโ€”and controversialโ€”academic theories in contemporary political discourse. The disciplineโ€™s key terms, such as โ€œsystemic racism,โ€ โ€œwhite privilege,โ€ โ€œwhite fragility,โ€ and โ€œracial equity,โ€ have become part of the common vocabulary and the basis for much of progressive policymaking. In 2020, the President of the United States addressed the debate over critical race theoryโ€™s role in policymaking with a speech denouncing it at the National Archives and an executive order banning critical race theoryโ€“inspired training programs from the federal government.1

Donald J. Trump, โ€œRemarks by President Trump at the White House Conference on American History,โ€ September 17, 2020, The American Mind, September 30,, 2020, https://americanmind.org/features/reclaiming-american-history/remarks-by-president-trump-at-the-white-house-conference-on-american-history/ (accessed February 17, 2021).๏ปฟ

The rise of critical race theory in recent years has been astonishing. For decades, the theory, which posits that Americaโ€™s institutions are โ€œcamouflagesโ€ for racial oppression,2

William F Tate IV, โ€œCritical Race Theory and Education: History, Theory, and Implications,โ€ Review of Research in Education, Vol. 22, No. 1 (January 1997), pp.195โ€“247.๏ปฟ had been relegated to the academic world, circulating in journals, law review articles, and conference presentations. Over the past decade, however, critical race theory has moved from obscurity to near ubiquity in Americaโ€™s academic, corporate, and governmental institutions. In recent years, a large number of schools, universities, and local governments have adopted โ€œantiracismโ€ or โ€œdiversity and inclusionโ€ policies based on critical race theory. In addition, federal agencies have implemented human resources programs based on critical race theory,3

Christopher F. Rufo, โ€œObscene Federal โ€˜Diversity Trainingโ€™ Scam Prospersโ€”Even Under Trump,โ€ New York Post Blog, July 16, 2020, https://www.ma https://nypost.com/2020/07/16/obscene-federal-diversity-training-scam-prospers-even-under-trump/ (accessed February 17, 2021).๏ปฟ philanthropies have pledged billions toward โ€œracial equityโ€ initiatives,4

David J. Maurrasse, โ€œPhilanthropy Responds to the Racial Equity Movement,โ€ GrantCraft Blog, July 21, 2020, https://grantcraft.org/content/blog/philanthropy-responds-to-the-racial-equity-movement (accessed February 17, 2021).๏ปฟ and hundreds of corporations have signaled their support for the new ideology of โ€œantiracism.โ€5

Reuters, โ€œFactbox: Corporations Pledge $1.7 Billion to Address Racism, Injustice,โ€ U.S. News & World Report, June 9, 2020, https://www.usnews.com/news/top-news/articles/2020-06-09/factbox-corporations-pledge-17-billion-to-address-racism-injustice (accessed February 17, 2021).๏ปฟ

Unfortunately, despite the superficial appeal of slogans like โ€œfighting racism,โ€ these policies will do little to alleviate poverty and inequality in the real world. As scholars such as Ron Haskins, Robert Rector, Isabel Sawhill, and others have demonstrated, the real drivers of American povertyโ€”for all racial groupsโ€”are the so-called background variables of family structure, educational attainment, and workforce participation.

In spite of the empirical evidence demonstrating the importance of these variables, however, the critical race theorists have sought to undermine them at every turn. They have argued that the nuclear family is a vestige of white supremacy,6

Ashley A. Walsdorf, Lorien S. Jordan, Christi R. McGeorge, and Margaret O. Caughy, โ€œWhite Supremacy and the Web of Family Science: Implications of the Missing Spider,โ€ Journal of Family Theory & Review, Vol. 12, No. 1 (March 2020), pp. 64โ€“79.๏ปฟ work requirements and entry-level employment are an extension of capitalist oppression,7

Wendy M. Limbert and Heather E. Bullock, โ€œโ€˜Playing the Foolโ€™: US Welfare Policy from a Critical Race Perspective,โ€ Feminism & Psychology, Vol. 15, No. 3 (August 2005), pp. 253โ€“274.๏ปฟ and achievement-based education is a historical artifact of racism and eugenics.8

Wayne Au, โ€œHiding Behind High-Stakes Testing: Meritocracy, Objectivity and Inequality in U.S. Education,โ€ The International Education Journal: Comparative Perspectives, Vol. 12, No. 2 (2013), pp. 7โ€“20, https://openjournals.library.sydney.edu.au/index.php/IEJ/article/viewFile/7453/7812 (accessed February 17, 2021).๏ปฟ โ€œPoverty,โ€ in the words of race theorist Kay Ann Taylor, โ€œis a structural, embedded, institutionalized, and systemic requirement to maintain capitalism’s efficacy; it is an ongoing outcome of hegemony, patriarchy, and a capitalistic economic structure.โ€9

Kay Ann Taylor, โ€œPovertyโ€™s Multiple Dimensionsโ€ Journal of Educational Controversy, Vol. 4, No. 1 (2009), https://cedar.wwu.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1086&context=jec21 (accessed February 17, 2021).๏ปฟ

Contrary to the doctrine of critical race theory, the solution to povertyโ€”for members of all racial groupsโ€”is to provide a pathway for stable two-parent households, achievement-based academic success, and full-time work for householders. If policymakers can close the gap for these critical background variables, the gap between various racial groups will follow in kind.

In order to address inequality, policymakers must begin with a rigorous understanding of what drives it and how the institutions of family, education, and work can help to reduce it. Although there is no quick or easy solution for this problem, the alternative proposed by critical race theoryโ€”in essence, the revolutionary overthrow of capitalism, tradition, and constitutionalismโ€”would be even worse.

Read Critical Race Theory Would Not Solve Racial Inequality: It Would Deepen It PDF

critical-race-theory-would-not-solve-racial-inequality

The Heritage Foundation
The Heritage Foundationhttps://www.heritage.org/
The Heritage Foundation formulates and promotes public policies based on free enterprise, limited government, individual freedom, traditional values, and strong national defense.

Columns

Made-in-America Entrepreneurs See Opportunities in Global Tariffs

Itโ€™s more than just a label. โ€œMade in Americaโ€ represents pride and the national spirit, says John Roy, CEO of Dawson Knives in Prescott, Arizona.

Easterโ€™s Christian hunt

Easter isn't another benevolent Sunday. It's the holy remembrance of the salvific victory Jesus Christ had over death and is the defining moment in human history.ย 

The 9-11 Commission Report to Be Revisited?

Trump Admin should reopen an investigation of events of 9/11 as it appears it was a criminal act to conceal theft of trillions of taxpayer dollars!

Legal Battles, Accusations of Bias as Americaโ€™s Public Media Faces Uncertain Future

Voice of America says it shares a message of freedom and hope, while the Trump administration calls it โ€˜radical propaganda.โ€™

Are Liberal Democrats Faking Things These Days?

The โ€œFighting Oligarchyโ€ rally in Nampa, Idaho has even AI applications confirming suspicions the video of AOC and her new bogus accent are doctored.

News

Fed Approves Capital Oneโ€“Discover Merger to Create 8th Largest US Bank

The Federal Reserve Board has given its approval for Capital One Financial Corporationโ€™s merger with Discover Financial Services in a $35.3 billion deal.

Education Department Asks Harvard for Foreign Fundersโ€™ List After University Submits Inaccurate Records

Dept of Ed sent โ€œrecords requestโ€ to Harvard Univ after review of institutionโ€™s reports found foreign funding disclosures were โ€œincomplete and inaccurate.โ€

Supreme Court Blocks Deportation of Alleged Venezuelan Gang Members for Now

Supreme Court temporarily blocked Trump admin from deporting Venezuelan men currently in immigration custody who are alleged to be criminal gang members.

Appeals Court Halts Judge Boasbergโ€™s Contempt Order in Deportations Case

Appeals court temporarily halted Boasbergโ€™s order finding probable cause Trump admin was in contempt for not complying with order prohibiting deportations.

Judge Blocks Trumpโ€™s Order Ending โ€˜Xโ€™ Gender Marker on Passports

A federal judge ruled against the Trump adminโ€™s EO banning the use of an โ€œXโ€ on passports marked by people self-identifying as neither male nor female.

ACLU Seeks Immediate Stay From Supreme Court of Deportation of Alleged Gang Members

ACLU filed an emergency request asking the Supreme Court to immediately block the Trump administration from deporting alleged Venezuelan gang members.

What to Know About the Florida State University Campus Shooting

Florida State Univ became a deadly crime scene as a student opened fire, killing two and injuring six others before he was shot and apprehended by law enforcement.

Judge Bars Trump Admin From Deporting Illegal Immigrants to Third Countries Without Warning or Torture Review

Federal judge barred Trump admin from deporting illegal immigrants with final removal orders to countries they would face persecution, torture, or death.
spot_img

Related Articles