Federal Appeals Court Rules FCC’s Universal Service Fund Is Illegal Tax

5Mind. The Meme Platform
The Epoch Times Header

USF is a program funded by fees and surcharges that uses billions of dollars to subsidize internet access.

A federal appeals court has ruled in favor of a conservative nonprofit in a case that challenged the legitimacy of the way the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) administers the Universal Service Fund (USF).

The court held that because the FCC relied on for-profit telecommunications companies to determine the USF surcharge, it functions as a tax that voters did not approve and so is unconstitutional.

In a 9–7 split decision issued by the full 5th Circuit Court of Appeals on July 24, the court sided with Washington-based nonprofit Consumers’ Research, finding that the USF surcharge is an illegal tax because, even though Congress delegated taxing power to the FCC, the agency relied on private companies to set the surcharge, in violation of Article I, Section I of the U.S. Constitution.

“In the Telecommunications Act of 1996, Congress delegated its taxing power to the Federal Communications Commission,” the majority opinion states. “FCC then subdelegated the taxing power to a private corporation. That private corporation, in turn, relied on for-profit telecommunications companies to determine how much American citizens would be forced to pay for the ‘universal service’ tax that appears on cell phone bills across the Nation. We hold this misbegotten tax violates Article I, § 1 of the Constitution.”

The nondelegation doctrine is the theory that Congress, which is vested with “all legislative powers” by Article I, Section I of the Constitution, cannot delegate that power to anyone else.

Several of the dissenting judges argued that the majority mischaracterized the U.S. Supreme Court’s precedents for separation of powers cases and that the decision leaves the political branches “powerless to govern.”

“This convergence sleight of hand not only undoes Supreme Court precedent but also leaves the political branches powerless to address this perceived constitutional deficiency, ignorant as to how to legislate and regulate in ways that will survive judicial review,” wrote Judge Carl Stewart in dissent.

Trent McCotter, a partner at Boyden Gray PLLC, the law firm representing Consumers’ First, praised the ruling.

By Tom Ozimek

Read Full Article on TheEpochTimes.com

Contact Your Elected Officials
The Epoch Times
The Epoch Timeshttps://www.theepochtimes.com/
Tired of biased news? The Epoch Times is truthful, factual news that other media outlets don't report. No spin. No agenda. Just honest journalism like it used to be.

The Party Of Hate Is Unleashing Political Violence

Sec. Scott Bessent placed blame for violence against President Trump squarely on the Democrat Party who are “normalizing this violence. It’s got to stop.”

‘Radical Right’ Restore Britain: The Remigration Dream Machine?

There is nothing wrong with being white, male, or straight—you are not the problem. The issue lies in systems, not individuals, and flawed DEI policies.

Trump 2.0’s Grand Strategy Against China Is Slowly But Surely Coming Together

Casual observers think Trump acts without strategy, but Trump 2.0 is steadily executing a calculated plan aimed at countering China’s global rise.

From legacy to liability

"When the Washington Post cut a third of its shrinking staff, leaders called it 'strategic restructuring'—like calling an iceberg a 'necessary pivot.'!"

Is Ghislaine Maxwell Free in Canada?

A video clip from a TikTok account ittybitty_ tara2...

EPA to Reform $5 Billion ‘Clean School Bus’ Program

EPA is revamping the Biden administration’s Clean School Bus (CSB) program, which focused on installing electric buses at U.S. schools.

Judge Says Jack Smith’s Final Report on Trump Can Never Be Released

A federal judge on Feb. 23 said that the final report on President Donald Trump compiled by a former special counsel shall not be released.

US Wins Its Record 11th Gold Medal at Winter Olympics

The U.S. Olympic team secured a record 11th Winter Games gold and could add another as men’s hockey faces Canada in the closing title final game.

Secret Service Agents Fatally Shoot Man Trying to Unlawfully Enter Mar-a-Lago

A man was shot and killed by Secret Service agents after allegedly trying to breach a secure perimeter at Trump’s Mar-a-Lago.

Trump Honors Angel Families, Proclaims National Day of Remembrance

President Trump issued a proclamation at the White House establishing Feb. 22 as National Angel Family Day to honor Americans killed by illegal immigrants.

US Trade Representative Says Nations Are Not Backing Out of Tariff Deals

U.S. trading partners who made deals under Trump show no plans to exit, even after the Supreme Court struck down most of his tariffs.

DOJ Fires Interim US Attorney Hours After Virginia Court Selects Him

The DOJ announced it fired the interim U.S. attorney for the Eastern District of Virginia just hours after judges on the court made the appointment.

Trump Admin Says Courts Need to Act on Tariff Refunds After Supreme Court Ruling

The White House is awaiting court guidance on tariff refunds after the Supreme Court struck down several import levies last week.
spot_img

Related Articles

Popular Categories

MAGA Business Central