How ‘Diversity’ Policing Fails Science

Wall Street Journal Header

An open-records request reveals that Texas Tech faculty penalize candidates for heterodox opinions.

At Texas Tech University, a candidate for a faculty job in the department of biological sciences was flagged by the department’s search committee for not knowing the difference between “equality” and “equity.” Another was flagged for his repeated use of the pronoun “he” when referring to professors. Still another was praised for having made a “land acknowledgment” during the interview process. A land acknowledgment is a statement noting that Native Americans once lived in what is now the United States.

Amidst the explosion of university diversity, equity and inclusion policies, Texas Tech’s biology department adopted its own DEI motion promising to “require and strongly weight a diversity statement from all candidates.” These short, written declarations are meant to summarize an academic job seeker’s past and potential contributions to DEI efforts on campus.

The biology department’s motion mandates that every search committee issue a report on its diversity statement evaluations. Through a Freedom of Information Act request, I have acquired the evaluations of more than a dozen job candidates.

To my knowledge, these documents—published in redacted form by the National Association of Scholars—are the first evaluations of prospective faculty DEI contributions to be made publicly available. They confirm what critics of DEI statements have long argued: That they inevitably act as ideological litmus tests.

One Texas Tech search committee penalized a candidate for espousing race-neutrality in teaching. The candidate “mentioned that DEI is not an issue because he respects his students and treats them equally,” the evaluation notes. “This indicates a lack of understanding of equity and inclusion issues.”

Another search committee flagged a candidate for failing to properly understand “the difference between equity and equality, even on re-direct,” noting that this suggests a “rather superficial understanding of DEI more generally.” This distinction arises frequently in DEI training, always as a markedly ideological talking point. According to the schema, equality means equal opportunity, but, to use the words of Vice President Kamala Harris, “Equitable treatment means we all end up in the same place.” Somehow, failing to explain that distinction reflects poorly on a biologist.

By John D. Sailer

Read Full Article on WSJ.com

Wall Street Journal
Wall Street Journalhttps://www.wsj.com/
The Wall Street Journal was founded in July 1889. Ever since, the Journal has led the way in chronicling the rise of industries in America and around the world.

Columns

Secession’s Hotel California

England’s King George III found out the hard way that the very genesis of the American ethos is running our own affairs liberated from bureaucratic control. 

Vaccine Induced AIDS is a Thing Now

Podcaster Liz Wheeler discusses a Yale Medical School report about mRNA COVID-19 vaccines causing what may now be determined to be "vaccine" induced AIDS.

Feral Pharma-Phile Libs Riot Over RFK Jr. Investigating SSRI Safety

The progressive meltdown ensued after Secretary RFK Jr. confirmed he is going to re-evaluate the scam that is SSRIs, which I have covered at AP previously.

Congressional Millionaires May Get DOGED!

Rumor says 163 members of Congress may undergo a forensic audit by DOGE to determine how their net worth so rapidly outpaced their $174,000 annual salaries.

Savory Schadenfreude: Lib Violins Out For Fired Bureaucrats Crying on TikTok

My friend asked me why I’m riding the Musk/Trump train. I’m not fully on board with Trump/Musk’s agenda and I don’t trust Musk further than I could throw him.

News

Buffett Offers Advice to Trump on Government Spending After Paying $26.8 Billion in Tax

In letter to shareholders, Warren Buffett reflected on Berkshire Hathaway’s successes while offering Trump admin some advice on stewardship of the U.S. economy.

Cartel-Linked Smugglers Arrested in US–Mexico Operation

An enforcement operation conducted as part of a bilateral cooperation between the US and Mexico led to disruptions and arrests in human smuggling operations.

Supreme Court Declines to Allow Trump Admin to Immediately Fire Watchdog Official

The U.S. Supreme Court on Feb. 21 declined to allow the Trump administration to immediately fire Office of Special Counsel chief Hampton Dellinger.

Grenell Outlines Trump’s Plan to Revamp the Kennedy Center

Richard Grenell, interim executive director of the Kennedy Center in Washington, outlined President Donald Trump’s vision for the performing arts venue.

Nation’s Biggest School Districts Stand to Lose Billions Over Trump’s DEI Order

Five largest U.S. public school districts to lose $5 billion in federal funds per year if they don't comply with Trump’s EOs barring ideologies such as DEI.

Los Angeles Mayor Removes Fire Chief Over Alleged Lack of Preparation for Palisades Fire

Mayor of Los Angeles, Karen Bass, removed city’s fire chief because chief had not prepared the dept to fight fires when they broke out earlier this year.

Inflation Expectations Jump to 30-Year High, Consumer Confidence Falls

U.S. consumer confidence tumbled to a 15-month low in Feb, as inflation fears surged and expectations for the broader economy and personal finances deteriorated.

Texas Measles Outbreak Grows to 90 Cases, Health Officials Say

A outbreak of measles cases in western Texas has grown to 90 cases since last month, according to new data released on Friday by state health officials.
spot_img

Related Articles

Popular Categories

MAGA Business Central