Joe Biden’s credibility has been shredded in Afghanistan

If Donald Trump were presiding over the debacle in Afghanistan, the US foreign policy establishment would be loudly condemning the irresponsibility and immorality of American strategy. Since it is Joe Biden in the White House there is instead, largely, an embarrassed silence.

It is true that Trump set the US on the path out of Afghanistan and began the delusional peace talks with the Taliban that have gone nowhere. But rather than reverse the withdrawal of troops, Biden accelerated it.

The horrific results are unfolding on the ground in Afghanistan, as the Taliban take city after city. The final collapse of the government looks inevitable. It may come just in time for the 20th anniversary of the 9/11 attacks that originally led to the US-led invasion of Afghanistan.

Earlier this week, Biden was channelling Edith Piaf, claiming he had no regrets about pulling the rug out from under the Afghan government. Last month, the president was still insisting that the “likelihood there’s going to be the Taliban overrunning everything and owning the whole country is highly unlikely”. Who knows what he will be saying next month? And, frankly, who cares? On Afghanistan, Biden’s credibility is now shot.

The broader strategic question is what the unfolding disaster in Afghanistan will do for US credibility around the world. Discussing the situation there as a question of high global politics feels distasteful while a tragedy unfolds on the ground. But, beyond simple war-weariness, Biden’s principal justification for the Afghan withdrawal was strategic. In recent remarks, he argued that the US cannot “remain tethered” to policies created in response “to a world as it was 20 years ago. We need to meet the threats where they are today.” The first threat that Biden identified was “the strategic competition with China”.

So how does America’s defeat in Afghanistan — in reality, a defeat for the entire western alliance — play into the growing rivalry between Washington and Beijing?

The US failure makes it much harder for Biden to push his core message that “America is back”. By contrast, it fits perfectly with two key messages pushed by the Chinese (and Russian) governments. First, that US power is in decline. Second, that American security guarantees cannot be relied upon.

If the US will not commit to a fight against the Taliban, there will be a question mark over whether America would really be willing to go to war with China or Russia. Yet America’s global network of alliances is based on the idea that, in the last resort, US troops would indeed be deployed to defend their allies in Asia, Europe and elsewhere.

China is already the dominant economic power in east Asia. But most Asian democracies look to the US as their main security partner. So it is very helpful to Beijing if Washington’s credibility is undermined. Of course, the situations and stakes in Taiwan or the South China Sea are different from those in Afghanistan. But events there will still resonate around the world.

The direct consequences for Beijing of US withdrawal from Afghanistan, which borders China, will be less welcome. The Chinese regime has adopted policies of mass internment and repression in Muslim-majority Xinjiang. The idea of the Uyghurs receiving support from a fundamentalist Taliban government will raise concerns in Beijing. So will the potential threat of terrorist bases in Afghanistan.

In time, China might face a classical superpower’s dilemma. Is it better to intervene militarily in turbulent Afghanistan, or to leave the country to its own devices? As Andrew Small of the European Council on Foreign Relations points out, Chinese commentary on Afghanistan is already replete with references to the country as the “graveyard of empires”.

In Washington, the parallel that will be uppermost in the minds of policymakers is Vietnam. There are already reports that America is trying to persuade the Taliban not to storm the US embassy in Kabul in order to avoid a repetition of the scenes when Saigon fell in 1975. Last month, Biden insisted that the “Taliban is not the North Vietnamese army. They’re not remotely comparable in terms of capability.” He may come to regret those words.

The Americans know, however, that if they decide to pull out the last remnants of the US presence in Kabul, they will be in effect signing the death warrant of the Afghan government. The collapse in morale which has already led to successive defeats for the Afghan army across the country would become irreversible. But, in truth, the situation already looks all but irrecoverable.

Unlike the Afghan government, however, the US administration has a few straws of hope to cling to. The end of the Vietnam war was indeed a debacle. Many questioned American power in its aftermath. But within fourteen years of the fall of Saigon, the cold war was over, and the west had won.

In the end, the struggle between the American and Soviet systems turned not on events in Vietnam but on the relative strengths of the two countries’ domestic economies and political systems. The current rivalry between the US and China may be determined in the same way. But that abstract thought is little comfort to the beleaguered people of Afghanistan.

By Gideon Rachman
gideon.rachman@ft.com

Read Original Article on FT.com

The Thinking Conservative
The Thinking Conservativehttps://www.thethinkingconservative.com/
The goal of THE THINKING CONSERVATIVE is to help us educate ourselves on conservative topics of importance to our freedom and our pursuit of happiness. We do this by sharing conservative opinions on all kinds of subjects, from all types of people, and all kinds of media, in a way that will challenge our perceptions and help us to make educated choices.

Columns

How could a British Canadian union solve the America Canada problem?

Combining the UK and Canada economy would revitalize both nations and their military ends any worry about Canada being a weak link in the free world.

Logan Act Violations Need Prosecution

Former members of Obama admin, Blinken, Nuland, Rice, and Vindman allegedly advised Zelenskyy to reject Trump’s peace and minerals deal in violation of Logan Act.

Pronoun Problems

Trump's campaign to restore common sense resulted in his2025 victory. His win was a death blow to the gender-bending pronoun pandemonium gripping the nation.

Movie Review: The Firing Squad

Although reviewers overuse the term “powerful”, attributing it to just about every film, The Firing Squad (2024) is truly powerful. It will pull at your heart.

Influencer Nick Sortor Catches Rep. Eric Swalwell Drunk!

Eric Swalwell PANICS when Nick Sortor asks about his Chinese spy girlfriend Fang Fang, and whether that’s a bigger national security threat than Elon Musk.

News

BlackRock to Buy Panama Canal Ports from Hong Kong Firm

A BlackRock-led consortium has reached an agreement to acquire two critical port operations in the Panama Canal from Hong Kong-based CK Hutchison Holdings Ltd.

CPAC, Other Conferences Reveal Conservative Landscape on Russia, Ukraine

Under Trump the US is refocusing on the Western Hemisphere, where more of its core interests lie and “America, it’s not [the] global policeman anymore.

Head of FBI New York Field Office Ordered to Retire Amid DOJ Probes

James Dennehy, head of FBI’s New York Field Office, reportedly emailed staff members to announce he has been asked to turn in his retirement papers.

Pentagon Announces $80 Million in Savings From First DOGE Review

Department of Defense has identified more than $80 million in wasteful spending through Musk and his DOGE team. It include DEI and climate change programs.

Transgender Ex-Military Member’s Surprising Take on Trump’s Policy

Two decades after transgender soldier was outed and discharged from the army she supports Trump’s decision to bar transgender people from military service.

Trump Considers 5 Cryptocurrencies for New National Strategic Reserve

Trump has announced a plan to establish the first U.S. Strategic Cryptocurrency Reserve (SCR), sending prices for all five of his named digital assets surging.

Bondi Vows to Release ‘Everything’ Related to Epstein, Says She Was Misled

AG Bondi provided details on controversy around release of files related to Jeffrey Epstein, saying she was misled and vowed to release “everything”.

Former NIH Director Francis Collins Retires From Agency

Dr. Francis Collins, who led the National Institutes of Health (NIH) when the COVID-19 pandemic hit, has stepped down from the federal government.
spot_img

Related Articles

Popular Categories

MAGA Business Central