Media Liable for Comments Posted on Their Facebook Pages: Australian High Court

The Epoch Times Logo

In a landmark decision, Australia’s apex judicial body, the High Court, has dismissed an appeal from major media outlets claiming they were not responsible for comments posted by readers or audience members on their social media pages.

Experts believe the judgement will have wider ramifications across not just media outlets but businesses, government entities, and community organisations, who will have to moderate comments even more stringently—or remove the option altogether—to ensure defamatory comments are not publicised.

The case in question revolved around Dylan Voller, a former inmate at the Don Dale Youth Detention Centre.

Voller sued the publishers of news outlets The Sydney Morning Herald, The Australian, and Sky News Australia over comments posted by individuals on their Facebook pages in 2016 and 2017.

While the news stories posted online were not defamatory, Voller’s lawyers argued that the comments featured in the posts were defamatory and that the media companies were legally liable.

An initial case was heard in 2019 by the Supreme Court of New South Wales (NSW), who found it in Voller’s favour. In 2020, the NSW Court of Appeal again ruled in Voller’s favour agreeing that the media outlets were the “publishers.”

The media companies appealed once more to the High Court of Australia—the final appellate body in the country—which found in favour of Voller with a five to two majority.

The news company’s lawyers had argued that they were not instrumental to—or were participants in—the allegedly defamatory third-party comments.

However, the court disagreed and found that in creating a Facebook page and posting content, the news outlets facilitated, encouraged, and therefore, assisted in the publication of comments, meaning they should be deemed the publishers.

The High Court also found that it did not matter that the comments function in Facebook could not be disabled at the time.

By Daniel Y. Teng

Read Full Article on TheEpochTimes.com

The Thinking Conservative
The Thinking Conservativehttps://www.thethinkingconservative.com/
The goal of THE THINKING CONSERVATIVE is to help us educate ourselves on conservative topics of importance to our freedom and our pursuit of happiness. We do this by sharing conservative opinions on all kinds of subjects, from all types of people, and all kinds of media, in a way that will challenge our perceptions and help us to make educated choices.

Columns

BOMBSHELL: DOGE Proves Democrats Guilty of Election Fraud!

As the old expression goes, “That didn’t take long!” Over...

Tariffs Will Make America Rich Again

The US won World War II because we could outproduce our enemies, Peter Navarro explained, and the American “arsenal of democracy” permitted the Allies to triumph.

America’s sport export

The popularity of baseball in Japan and Korea contrasts to a shrinking American audience where the average age of your MLB fan is a 57-year-old Caucasian man. 

The Black Conservative Manifesto, 2025

Black conservatives present this manifesto to the Black community and the nation as a blueprint for progress and improvement. 

 CIA Looked for the Ark of the Covenant?

The CIA's Project Sunstreak assembled people gifted in psychoenergetics to do “remote viewing” in an attempt to locate the Ark of the Covenant.

News

Hegseth: Men and Women in Combat Must Meet ‘Same, High Standard’

Today at the Department of Defense all combat roles are open to men and women BUT they must all meet the same, high standard, Def. Sec. Hegseth said.

Supreme Court Seems Sympathetic to Catholic Charity in Religious Rights Dispute

The U.S. Supreme Court on March 31 seemed inclined to side with a Wisconsin Catholic charity that argues that it should not have to pay unemployment tax.

US Deports 17 Accused Terrorist Gang Members to El Salvador, Rubio Says

U.S. officials transferred 17 accused Tren de Aragua and MS-13 terrorist gang members to El Salvador on Mar. 30, Sec. of State Marco Rubio confirmed.

Musk Mobilizes Support for Wisconsin Judicial Contest

Musk handed out $2 million to publicize a Republican-backed candidate for state Supreme Court, saying “I think this will be important for the future of civilization.”

State’s Bid to Cut Medicaid Funding to Planned Parenthood Hits Supreme Court

U.S. Supreme Court justices may have to determine whether federal law unambiguously bestows Medicaid patients with the right to choose a specific provider.

Why Eggs Are Cheaper in Mexico and Canada

Canada and Mexico have active federal measures to control the price of eggs, while the United States does not.

Top FDA Vaccine Official Peter Marks Resigns From Agency

Dr. Peter Marks, who was involved in Operation Warp Speed to produce COVID-19 vaccines, submitted his resignation citing Sec. RFK Jr's initiatives.
spot_img

Related Articles

Popular Categories

MAGA Business Central