Originalism: A Debate – Should the U.S. Constitution be interpreted according to its Original Public Meaning?

5Mind. The Meme Platform
The Heritage Foundation Header

It was over three decades ago, when then-Attorney General Ed Meese initiated an important spirited national debate about the proper application of our most important governing document—the U.S. Constitution. Since then, Originalism has emerged as a serious theory of constitutional interpretation that has permeated the judiciary and the academy. Originalists believe that the Constitution and laws should be interpreted based on their actual text and original public meaning. Conversely, proponents of a “Living Constitution,” stress the need to adapt the Constitution “to cope with current problems and current needs.” These two theories will go head-to-head in a spirited debate with two well-known constitutional scholars, John Eastman and Michael Gerhardt.

Introduction

Edwin Meese lll: Ronald Reagan Distinguished Fellow Emeritus, The Heritage Foundation

Arguing the Affirmative

John Eastman: Henry Salvatori Professor of Law and Community Service, Chapman University’s Dale E. Fowler School of Law and Director, Center for Constitutional Jurisprudence, Claremont Institute

Arguing the Negative

Michael Gerhardt: Samuel Ashe Distinguished Professor in Constitutional Law, University of North Carolina School of Law

Moderator

John Malcolm: Vice President, Institute for Constitutional Government

Location

The Heritage Foundation, 214 Massachusetts Ave NE, Washington, DC 20002

Contact Your Elected Officials
The Heritage Foundation
The Heritage Foundationhttps://www.heritage.org/
The Heritage Foundation formulates and promotes public policies based on free enterprise, limited government, individual freedom, traditional values, and strong national defense.

Trump’s SCOTUS “Foreign Interests” Comment Explained

We've addressed claims Trump’s tariffs were illegal, but not his accusation that court members are influenced by foreign interests.

The Party Of Hate Is Unleashing Political Violence

Sec. Scott Bessent placed blame for violence against President Trump squarely on the Democrat Party who are “normalizing this violence. It’s got to stop.”

‘Radical Right’ Restore Britain: The Remigration Dream Machine?

There is nothing wrong with being white, male, or straight—you are not the problem. The issue lies in systems, not individuals, and flawed DEI policies.

Trump 2.0’s Grand Strategy Against China Is Slowly But Surely Coming Together

Casual observers think Trump acts without strategy, but Trump 2.0 is steadily executing a calculated plan aimed at countering China’s global rise.

From legacy to liability

"When the Washington Post cut a third of its shrinking staff, leaders called it 'strategic restructuring'—like calling an iceberg a 'necessary pivot.'!"

Democrats Lay Out Plans to Ride Affordability to ‘Big Blue Wave’ in Midterms

House Democrats opened their 2026 issues conference on Feb. 25 with a unified pitch to voters: The party that lowers costs wins in November.

15 States Sue RFK Jr. Over Changes to Vaccine Schedule

California and 14 other states sued federal health agencies and Health Sec. Robert F. Kennedy Jr. over the recently revised childhood vaccine schedule.

Larry Summers Resigns From Harvard in Epstein File Fallout

Former Harvard University president Larry Summers will step down amid fallout over ties to Jeffrey Epstein.

FBI Raids Home, Office of Los Angeles Schools Superintendent

The FBI served a court-authorized warrant at the home and district office of Los Angeles Unified School District Superintendent Alberto Carvalho.

10 Memorable Moments From Trump’s State of the Union Address

President Trump delivered the longest SOYU address in recorded U.S. history, punctuating it with emotional moments and real-life stories to illustrate policy.

Trump Proposes New Retirement Account for US Workers Without 401(k) Access

During his State of the Union, President Trump proposed a new retirement program giving Americans without 401(k)s access to savings accounts.

Trump Hails ‘Turnaround for the Ages’ in State of the Union

President Trump delivers first second-term State of the Union, touting economic gains and saying his America First agenda is working for Americans.

Trump to Announce New Policies in State of the Union Address, White House Says

White House press secretary Karoline Leavitt said President Trump’s first second-term State of the Union will feature new policy announcements.
spot_img

Related Articles

Popular Categories

MAGA Business Central