Originalism: A Debate – Should the U.S. Constitution be interpreted according to its Original Public Meaning?

5Mind. The Meme Platform
The Heritage Foundation Header

It was over three decades ago, when then-Attorney General Ed Meese initiated an important spirited national debate about the proper application of our most important governing documentโ€”the U.S. Constitution. Since then, Originalism has emerged as a serious theory of constitutional interpretation that has permeated the judiciary and the academy. Originalists believe that the Constitution and laws should be interpreted based on their actual text and original public meaning. Conversely, proponents of a โ€œLiving Constitution,โ€ stress the need to adapt the Constitution โ€œto cope with current problems and current needs.โ€ These two theories will go head-to-head in a spirited debate with two well-known constitutional scholars, John Eastman and Michael Gerhardt.

Introduction

Edwin Meese lll: Ronald Reagan Distinguished Fellow Emeritus, The Heritage Foundation

Arguing the Affirmative

John Eastman: Henry Salvatori Professor of Law and Community Service, Chapman University’s Dale E. Fowler School of Law and Director, Center for Constitutional Jurisprudence, Claremont Institute

Arguing the Negative

Michael Gerhardt: Samuel Ashe Distinguished Professor in Constitutional Law, University of North Carolina School of Law

Moderator

John Malcolm: Vice President, Institute for Constitutional Government

Location

The Heritage Foundation, 214 Massachusetts Ave NE, Washington, DC 20002

Contact Your Elected Officials
The Heritage Foundation
The Heritage Foundationhttps://www.heritage.org/
The Heritage Foundation formulates and promotes public policies based on free enterprise, limited government, individual freedom, traditional values, and strong national defense.

Never and somehow again

When dealing with an all-volunteer force, retention will always be an issue especially when civilian society is competing for the same talent.

In Memoriam: Democrat Capos Lick Dick Cheneyโ€™s Boots

The unindicted, unrepentant war criminal Dick Cheney, you may have heard, kicked the bucket earlier this week.

The Business of Hating America

Many Americans mistake discomfort for oppression and inconvenience for crisis, confusing the safety of abundance with the struggle of true hardship.

A Defining Moment: Will Populist Promises Collapse New York City?

New York City elected a candidate promising rent freezes, free transit, universal childcare, and higher corporate taxesโ€”pledges that may clash with fiscal reality.

Another Motive to Kill Charlie Kirk

Since the last article about Kirk's assassination, we have found a third and more powerful motive for the murder of Charlie Kirk.

US to Boycott G20 Over South Africaโ€™s โ€˜Rights Abusesโ€™ of Afrikaners

Trump bars U.S. officials from attending G20 summit in South Africa, citing human rights abuses against white Afrikaners and illegal land seizures.

The Warning Signs of a โ€˜K-shapedโ€™ Split in the US Economy

Concerns of a K-shaped economy in the United States, with its characteristic split, have increased in recent months.

USDA Must Update Genetically Modified Food Labeling Requirements: Court

A U.S. appeals court ruled the Agriculture Dept. wrongly exempted undetectable genetically modified foods from mandatory labeling requirements.

Trump Considers Sanctions Exemption for Hungary as He Hosts Orban

Trump said he may exempt Hungary from sanctions, noting itโ€™s hard for Orban to secure oil and gas from elsewhere. โ€œWeโ€™re looking at it,โ€ he told reporters.

US Government Revokes 80,000 Visas

The Trump administration wonโ€™t hesitate to revoke visas of foreigners who โ€˜undermine our laws', the US State Dept. said after 80,000 visas were revoked.

Trump to Host Central Asian Leaders as US Shores Up Critical Mineral Supply

President Trump is hosting Central Asian leaders at the White House on Nov. 6, amid fast-tracked efforts to de-risk supply chains from China.

Trump Drafting Executive Order on Election Integrity After Alleging Ballot Fraud in California

White House press secretary Karoline Leavitt said an executive order is being drafted to strengthen U.S. elections and curb mail-in ballot fraud.
spot_img

Related Articles