Sen. Cruz Calls on Trump Administration to Submit Obama-Biden Iran Nuclear Deal & Paris Climate Agreement to Senate as Formal Treaties

โ€˜Only by properly submitting these disastrous deals as treaties will the senate be able to satisfy its constitutional role to provide advice and consent in the event any future administration attempts to revive themโ€™

WASHINGTON, D.C. – U.S. Sen. Ted Cruz (R-Texas), member of the Senate Foreign Relations Committee, this week called on the Trump administration to submit both the Iran Nuclear Deal and Paris Climate Agreement to the Senate as formal treaties.

In a letter to President Trump and Secretary of State Mike Pompeo, Sen. Cruz slammed the Obama-Biden administration for undermining the Senate’s constitutional role in both the Iran Nuclear Deal and Paris Agreement negotiations, writing:

“Multiple previous administrations […] have undermined the Senate’s constitutional role by negotiating significant international agreements and then refusing to submit them to the Senate for its advice and consent. Most recently-and most egregiously-President Obama refused to submit either the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action (the โ€˜Iran Deal’), or the United Nations Paris Climate Agreement (the โ€˜Paris Agreement’) to the Senate as a treaty.”

He continued:

“These agreements could and should have been submitted as treaties given their sweeping scope and immense implications for American foreign and domestic policy. The Paris Agreement, for example, was lauded as the โ€˜most ambitious climate change agreement in history.’ The Iran Deal, meanwhile, was situated as โ€˜the most consequential foreign policy debate that our country has had since the invasion of Iraq.'”

He concluded, urging the Trump administration to submit both agreements to the Senate as formal treaties:

Your administration has rightly changed course as a matter of substantive policy by withdrawing from both the Iran Deal and the Paris Agreement. This was a great accomplishment for the American people.

“I urge you now also to remedy the harm done to the balance of powers by submitting the Iran Deal and the Paris Agreement to the Senate as treaties. Only by submitting them to the Senate will the Senate be able to satisfy its constitutional role to provide advice and consent in the event any future administration attempts to revive these dangerous deals.”

Sen. Cruz has led the fight against the Obama-Biden Iran Nuclear Deal since it wasย first negotiated. Since the U.S. withdrawal, he has pushed for anย end to oil waivers,ย an end to nuclear waivers, andย for invoking the U.N. snapback mechanism to restore international sanctions on Iran. In September, Sen. Cruzย applaudedย the Trump administration for enforcing snapback sanctions on Iran and finalizing the end of the Iran Nuclear Deal. Learn more about his fight here.

In 2017, Sen. Cruz urged President Trump to act on his campaign promise to “rip up” the Paris Climate Agreement in an op-ed on CNN.com, where he wrote, “We simply cannot afford an agreement that puts thousands of Americans out of work, increases their energy costs and devastates our core industries.” Read Sen. Cruz’s op-edย here. Shortly thereafter, President Trumpย announcedย the U.S. wouldย withdrawย from the agreement.

Read the full letterย hereย and below.

December 21, 2020

The Honorable Donald J. Trump
President of the United States
The White House
1600 Pennsylvania Ave NW
Washington, D.C. 20500

The Honorable Michael Pompeo
Secretary of State
U.S. Department of State
2201 C. Street NW
Washington, D.C. 20230

Dear President Trump and Secretary Pompeo,

The Constitution grants the Senate a significant, unique, and indispensable role in developing American foreign policy through treaties. Specifically, Article II, Section 2, Clause 2, provides that the President “shall have the Power, by and with the Advice and Consent of the Senate, to make Treaties, provided two-thirds of the Senators present concur.”

Multiple previous administrations, however, have undermined the Senate’s constitutional role by negotiating significant international agreements and then refusing to submit them to the Senate for its advice and consent. Most recently-and most egregiously-President Obama refused to submit either the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action (the “Iran Deal”), or the United Nations Paris Climate Agreement (the “Paris Agreement”) to the Senate as a treaty.

These agreements could and should have been submitted as treaties given their sweeping scope and immense implications for American foreign and domestic policy. The Paris Agreement, for example, was lauded as the “most ambitious climate change agreement in history.” The Iran Deal, meanwhile, was situated as “the most consequential foreign policy debate that our country has had since the invasion of Iraq.”

That is why numerous Senators demanded that the administration submit both agreements to the Senate for advice and consent. Thirty-four Senators co-sponsored a resolution “expressing the sense of Congress that the President should submit the Paris climate change agreement to the Senate for its advice and consent.” Because Obama refused to do so, Senator Risch, the current Chairman of the Senate Foreign Relations Committee, later issued a joint statement with Senator Crapo stating: “There are many reasons the Paris Climate Accord was a bad deal. Not the least of which is that it was agreed to unilaterally by the Obama Administration, violating our Constitution’s requirement that all treaties be passed by a two-thirds vote in the Senate.” Similarly, in an interview addressing the Iran Deal, Senator Risch stated that President Obama “needed to submit it to the United States Senate for ratification under the Constitution. It was a treaty.”

The only reason the Obama administration refused to submit these agreements to the Senate as treaties was that it knew that the agreements were deeply unpopular and doomed for defeat.

Then-Secretary of State John Kerry was shockingly candid about this end-run around the Senate’s Constitutional prerogative. When asked by Rep. Ribble of Wisconsin why the deal was not considered a treaty, he replied: “I spent quite a few years trying to get a lot of treaties through the United States Senate, and frankly, it’s become physically impossible. That’s why. Because you can’t pass a treaty anymore.” The same was true for the Paris Agreement. The New York Times in 2014 reported that “the Obama administration is working to forge a sweeping international climate change agreement to compel nations to cut their planet-warming fossil fuel emissions, but without ratification from Congress” because there was “no chance” that the “Senate [would] ratify a climate change treaty in the near future.”

The Obama administration attempted to justify its decision to sideline the Senate by structuring the agreements in a way that allowed it to publicly assert that the agreements were not legally binding and therefore not treaties subject to the Senate’s advice and consent-even though an Obama-era State Department legal memorandum determined the Paris Agreement “does contain legally binding obligations that would apply to the United States,” and then-President Obama himself contextualized the Iran Deal by saying that “[a]s was true in previous treaties, it does not resolve all problems.” But this strategic restructuring is itself a significant threat to the separation of powers and the Senate’s constitutional role in foreign affairs. As the nonpartisan Congressional Research Service wrote in a canonical 2001 study of the treaty power prepared for the United States Committee on Foreign Relations:

The main threat of erosion of the Senate treaty power comes not from the international agreements that are submitted as treaties, however, but from the many international agreements that are not submitted for its consent. In addition to concluding hundreds of executive agreements, Presidents have made important commitments that they considered politically binding but not legally binding. Maintaining the Senate role in treaties requires overseeing all international agreements to assure that agreements that should be treaties are submitted to the Senate.

Simply put, a President does great damage to the separation of powers if he arrogates the treaty power entirely to himself by altering the terms of an agreement so that most or all of the provisions are not legally binding, even as they politically and practically commit United States to a course of action opposed by Congress. See 11 F.A.M. ยง 723 (listing criteria for determining whether an agreement is a treaty, including “the extent to which the agreement involves commitments or risks affecting the nation as a whole” and the “preference of the Congress”).

Your administration has rightly changed course as a matter of substantive policy by withdrawing from both the Iran Deal and the Paris Agreement. This was a great accomplishment for the American people.

I urge you now also to remedy the harm done to the balance of powers by submitting the Iran Deal and the Paris Agreement to the Senate as treaties. Only by submitting them to the Senate will the Senate be able to satisfy its constitutional role to provide advice and consent in the event any future administration attempts to revive these dangerous deals.

Sincerely,

/s/

###

The Thinking Conservative
The Thinking Conservativehttps://www.thethinkingconservative.com/
The goal of THE THINKING CONSERVATIVE is to help us educate ourselves on conservative topics of importance to our freedom and our pursuit of happiness. We do this by sharing conservative opinions on all kinds of subjects, from all types of people, and all kinds of media, in a way that will challenge our perceptions and help us to make educated choices.

Columns

Made-in-America Entrepreneurs See Opportunities in Global Tariffs

Itโ€™s more than just a label. โ€œMade in Americaโ€ represents pride and the national spirit, says John Roy, CEO of Dawson Knives in Prescott, Arizona.

Easterโ€™s Christian hunt

Easter isn't another benevolent Sunday. It's the holy remembrance of the salvific victory Jesus Christ had over death and is the defining moment in human history.ย 

The 9-11 Commission Report to Be Revisited?

Trump Admin should reopen an investigation of events of 9/11 as it appears it was a criminal act to conceal theft of trillions of taxpayer dollars!

Legal Battles, Accusations of Bias as Americaโ€™s Public Media Faces Uncertain Future

Voice of America says it shares a message of freedom and hope, while the Trump administration calls it โ€˜radical propaganda.โ€™

Are Liberal Democrats Faking Things These Days?

The โ€œFighting Oligarchyโ€ rally in Nampa, Idaho has even AI applications confirming suspicions the video of AOC and her new bogus accent are doctored.

News

Fed Approves Capital Oneโ€“Discover Merger to Create 8th Largest US Bank

The Federal Reserve Board has given its approval for Capital One Financial Corporationโ€™s merger with Discover Financial Services in a $35.3 billion deal.

Education Department Asks Harvard for Foreign Fundersโ€™ List After University Submits Inaccurate Records

Dept of Ed sent โ€œrecords requestโ€ to Harvard Univ after review of institutionโ€™s reports found foreign funding disclosures were โ€œincomplete and inaccurate.โ€

Supreme Court Blocks Deportation of Alleged Venezuelan Gang Members for Now

Supreme Court temporarily blocked Trump admin from deporting Venezuelan men currently in immigration custody who are alleged to be criminal gang members.

Appeals Court Halts Judge Boasbergโ€™s Contempt Order in Deportations Case

Appeals court temporarily halted Boasbergโ€™s order finding probable cause Trump admin was in contempt for not complying with order prohibiting deportations.

Judge Blocks Trumpโ€™s Order Ending โ€˜Xโ€™ Gender Marker on Passports

A federal judge ruled against the Trump adminโ€™s EO banning the use of an โ€œXโ€ on passports marked by people self-identifying as neither male nor female.

ACLU Seeks Immediate Stay From Supreme Court of Deportation of Alleged Gang Members

ACLU filed an emergency request asking the Supreme Court to immediately block the Trump administration from deporting alleged Venezuelan gang members.

What to Know About the Florida State University Campus Shooting

Florida State Univ became a deadly crime scene as a student opened fire, killing two and injuring six others before he was shot and apprehended by law enforcement.

Judge Bars Trump Admin From Deporting Illegal Immigrants to Third Countries Without Warning or Torture Review

Federal judge barred Trump admin from deporting illegal immigrants with final removal orders to countries they would face persecution, torture, or death.
spot_img

Related Articles