Senator Hawley Blasts Google for Threatening Conservative Outlets and Section 230 Hypocrisy

Wednesday, June 17, 2020

Following reports that Google threatened to demonetize The Federalist based on its comments section, U.S. Senator Josh Hawley (R-Mo.) sent a letter to Google CEO Sundar Pichai blasting the company for political censorship. Senator Hawley writes that Google is aware of its dominance in online advertising and, based on information provided by foreign dark-money groups, is attempting to use that power to target conservative outlets and dissenting voices.

Senator Hawley writes, “Moreover, it is profoundly disingenuous for Google to insist on applying a standard to other companies that it disclaims for itself. Google and other technology companies routinely rely on the protections afforded by Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act to evade responsibility for any third-party content posted on the platforms they offer. Now, Google apparently declines to extend a similar protection to those companies that rely on its own services. And the hypocrisy does not stop there: if the contents of a website’s comments sections are sufficient to declare that site offensive and banish it from Google’s platform, one wonders what to make of the cesspit that is the comments section of YouTube. In short, Google demands minimum oversight for itself, but maximum power over those who use its platform.”

Senator Hawley introduced a bill today to empower Americans to sue Big Tech companies who act in bad faith, such as by selectively censoring political speech, and subject companies in violation to a $5,000 fine (or actual damages, if higher) plus attorney’s fees.

Read the full letter here or below.

June 17, 2020

Mr. Sundar Pichai
Chief Executive Officer
Google, LLC
1600 Amphitheater Parkway
Mountain View, CA 94043

Dear Mr. Pichai:

Google’s decision to threaten the conservative publication The Federalist with removal from the Google Ads platform—based on, apparently, the contents of its comments section—is startling, but apparently just the latest instance of Google’s long pattern of targeting any perspectives that deviate from its preferred party line.

Your company is well aware of the central role played by advertising in the modern online ecosystem, and has spent years amassing an enormous trove of internet users’ data through the Google Ads platform. That, in turn, has granted your company vast powers to shape what users see, believe, and buy. Given the breadth of Google’s data collection practices, the power of Google’s behavioral advertising toolkit, and Google’s sheer market dominance, publishers are forced to do whatever your company demands in order to effectively serve their audiences. Now, your company is attempting to further manipulate the information marketplace by transforming advertising platform access into a cudgel wielded against dissenting voices.

An NBC News report[1] lays the responsibility for this move at the feet of the “Center for Countering Digital Hate,” a UK-based think tank devoted to squelching speech it disagrees with. The Center’s mission statement is to “encourage antisocial online behaviour to be met with opprobrium and consequence both on- and offline,” and the Center seeks to ensure that speech not meeting its standards will “lead to serious offline consequences.”[2] In particular, the Center runs the “Stop Funding Fake News” website,[3] which includes websites like Breitbart and American Greatness among its media targets. The Center demands that outlets be blacklisted by advertisers for such spurious “offenses” as criticizing dominant narratives surrounding climate change.[4]

Foreign dark-money groups like the Center have no place in adjudicating American political discourse.  And making matters worse, NBC proudly claims responsibility for bringing the Center’s faulty work to Google’s attention.

Moreover, it is profoundly disingenuous for Google to insist on applying a standard to other companies that it disclaims for itself. Google and other technology companies routinely rely on the protections afforded by Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act to evade responsibility for any third-party content posted on the platforms they offer. Now, Google apparently declines to extend a similar protection to those companies that rely on its own services. And the hypocrisy does not stop there: if the contents of a website’s comments sections are sufficient to declare that site offensive and banish it from Google’s platform, one wonders what to make of the cesspit that is the comments section of YouTube. In short, Google demands minimum oversight for itself, but maximum power over those who use its platform.

None of this, apparently, matters to Google. Instead, what’s driving Google’s policy appears to be little more than the politically-motivated opinion commentary of a foreign think tank, as filtered through a legacy media organization bent on muzzling its rivals. If conservative outlets are not welcome on the Google Ads platform, your company should have the courage to say so.

This long pattern of discriminatory treatment must stop. It is well past time for Congress to act. And I assure you that Congress will.

Sincerely,

Josh Hawley
United States Senator

The Thinking Conservative
The Thinking Conservativehttps://www.thethinkingconservative.com/
The goal of THE THINKING CONSERVATIVE is to help us educate ourselves on conservative topics of importance to our freedom and our pursuit of happiness. We do this by sharing conservative opinions on all kinds of subjects, from all types of people, and all kinds of media, in a way that will challenge our perceptions and help us to make educated choices.

Columns

Lefty Activist Judges are Obstructing Trump’s Presidency

Activist judge’s ruling to block President Donald Trump from being able to execute his Constitutional Article 2 Powers pose a real “Constitutional crisis”.

France’s Next Quarterly Nuclear Drills Might Become Prestige-Building Exercises With Poland

Europe wonders what form Macron’s plans to extend his nuclear umbrella over the continent could take, considering risks entailed after Moscow’s negative reaction.

RFK Jr. Nukes HHS ‘Research’ Grants Designed to Stamp Out ‘Vaccine Hesitancy’

RFK Jr. must be waiting to get data firmly on his side before yanking COVID shots off the market and delivering pharmaceutical criminals to the DOJ.

An Actual Deep State Coup is Exposed in a CIA Email

Journalist John Solomon of “Just the News” on Real America’s Voice dropped a BOMBSHELL news report that appears to be old news revisited.

The new economics of compassionatlism

The aftermath of the Covid 19 pandemic has seen a global turn to stagflation, in which the cost of good and services increases regardless of economic growth.

News

FBI Director Responds to ‘Alarming Rise’ in Recent Swatting Incidents

FBI Dir. Kash Patel said federal law enforcement bureau is investigating “swatting” incidents that have targeted certain media figures in recent days.

Trump Admin Asks Supreme Court to Unblock Birthright Citizenship Order

Trump admin asked Supreme Court to roll back multiple preliminary injunctions courts have issued against his EO to restrict birthright citizenship.

NIH Wants to Cap Funding for Indirect Research Costs—What Are They?

NIH is the world’s largest funder of medical research, granting billions to colleges and universities yearly. Trump admin seeks to cap paid overhead costs.

Border Apprehensions of Illegal Immigrants Hit Lowest in History, CBP Says

Number of illegal immigrants apprehended by authorities declined 94% year-over-year under Trump, according to latest figures released by CBP.

98 Protesters Arrested After Occupying Trump Tower to Demand Release of Pro-Palestinian Activist

Police arrested protesters occupying lobby of Trump Tower in NYC, staging demonstration supporting Palestine and against arrest of Mahmoud Khalil.

Judge Rules Against Trump in Labor Case With Implications for DOGE

U.S. District Judge Sparkle Sooknanan ordered President Donald Trump...

After Deadly Crashes, Long-Overdue Aviation Updates Accelerate

The Trump administration is moving to bolster air travel...

RFK Jr. Warns Against Vaccinating Chickens for Bird Flu

HHS Sec. RFK, Jr. advised against providing vaccines to poultry amid a bird flu outbreak, as leaky vaccines can turn flocks into mutation factories.
spot_img

Related Articles

Popular Categories

MAGA Business Central