Supreme Court Declines X’s Challenge to Surveillance Gag Order

Contact Your Elected Officials
The Epoch Times Header

Elon Musk’s social media company had appealed against a federal gag order preventing it from disclosing government surveillance of X users.

The Supreme Court declined to take up an appeal by X, formerly known as Twitter, that challenged a law preventing the company from disclosing how often the federal government sought monitoring of social media users.

X had said the U.S. government’s ban on disclosing the exact number of receipts of national security-related requests for surveillance of users was unconstitutional.

The firm is owned by billionaire entrepreneur Elon Musk, who also heads SpaceX and Tesla.

The Supreme Court rejected the petition for certiorari, or review, in X Corp. v. Garland in an unsigned order on Jan. 8.

No justices dissented. The court didn’t explain its decision.

At least four of the nine justices must vote to grant the petition for the case to advance to the oral argument stage.

U.S. Attorney General Merrick Garland was the lead respondent in the appeal.

The decision came after an appeals court decision in August showed that special counsel Jack Smith had secured a search warrant in early 2023 for the Twitter account of former President Donald Trump as part of a federal criminal probe of the former president over alleged election interference.

X didn’t immediately hand over the materials sought in the warrant and asked a court to halt an order preventing the company from informing President Trump or anyone else of the existence of the warrant, according to a CNBC summary.

A federal district court fined X $350,000 for contempt for missing the handover deadline.

An appeals court turned away X’s request to void the contempt ruling and nondisclosure order. The company argued that the order infringed on its constitutional right to communicate with President Trump, its user.

The incident was not referenced in X’s petition.

The federal government carries out surveillance of Americans and foreign nationals by issuing “national security process,” or legal demands, to electronic communication service providers such as X, according to the petition.

By Matthew Vadum

Read Full Article on TheEpochTimes.com

The Epoch Times
The Epoch Timeshttps://www.theepochtimes.com/
Tired of biased news? The Epoch Times is truthful, factual news that other media outlets don't report. No spin. No agenda. Just honest journalism like it used to be.

Child-Diddling Migrant Invokes Curious ‘I Thought She Was My Wife’ Defense

Convicted of groping a sleeping schoolgirl on a flight, Javed Inamdar offered bizarre defenses that made O.J. Simpson’s glove excuse seem credible.

What’s The Real Reason Why The Economist Wants Europe To Spend $400 Billion More On Ukraine?

The Economist urges Europe’s elites to fund Ukraine’s $390B recovery, arguing it’s cheaper than facing the costs of inaction over the next four years.

Fourth and funded: The business of buyouts

Through week ten of the college football season, the ledger on what universities owe their former coaches in buyouts was nearly $185 million. 

Deflating Portland: Why Antifa Went from Black Blok to Inflatable Costumes

Antifa's transformation from militant to mascot is so absurd it's almost comedic. Yet beneath the humor lies something calculated. It’s all about optics.

The Affordable Care Act: The Great Deception of “Affordable”

When the Affordable Care Act was introduced, people trusted what they were told. The truth is, the ACA has done the exact opposite of what it claimed.

Democrats Cast Election Night as a Comeback

Democrats hailed election-night wins across several states as proof of a political comeback ahead of the 2026 midterms.

Vance Says Republicans Have to Work on ‘Turning Out Voters’ in Next Election

Vice President JD Vance urged Republicans to “do better” at boosting voter turnout after Democrats scored key wins in New York City, Virginia, and New Jersey.

34 Illegal Immigrant Truck Drivers Arrested in Oklahoma: ICE

A two-day operation led to the arrest of 70 illegal immigrants in Oklahoma, which included 34 drivers operating a semi-truck or a commercial vehicle.

US Private Sector Adds 42,000 New Jobs in October: ADP

U.S. private-sector job creation rebounded last month as employment conditions could be showing signs of improving, according to data from ADP.

Trump Re-Nominates Jared Isaacman for NASA Administrator

Trailblazing civilian astronaut Jared Isaacman is once again President Donald Trump’s choice for NASA’s administrator.

US Agencies Terminate 103 Wasteful Contracts With $4.4 Billion Ceiling Value: DOGE

Government agencies canceled 103 wasteful contracts worth $4.4 billion, saving $103 million in five days, according to the Department of Government Efficiency.

Food Stamp Payments Could Restart by Wednesday as Ordered by Judge: Bessent

The Trump administration awaits court decisions on funding food stamp benefits for low-income Americans amid the ongoing government shutdown.

Trump Threatens Nigeria With US Military Action If It Doesn’t Confront Killings of Christians

President Trump on Nov. 1 threatened military action in Nigeria if the West African country doesn’t do more to halt the killing of Christians.
spot_img

Related Articles

Popular Categories

MAGA Business Central