The New Egyptian Constitution: An Initial Assessment of its Merits and Flaws

Egypt cannot be described as a religious state, given that political power remains firmly in the hands of civilians, but religion will now play a real role in inspiring how the state is to function. And military trials of civilians have been elevated to a constitutional principle.

Following the results of the referendum, in which 63.8% of voters appear to have approved the text, the new Egyptian constitution is now the law of the land.  The turnout was far lower than anyone expected, with just over 32.9% of the population making their way to the polls, which means that the constitution has been approved by a mere 21% of eligible voters, clearly not a resounding victory for its proponents.

The poor showing will have a number of consequences, including the prospect that the new constitution’s popular legitimacy may be challenged for some time to come, which in turn will detract from the effort to resolve many of the more pressing problems that Egypt is facing today.

The debate surrounding the new constitution has been acrimonious to say the least.  Many of the constitution’s most ardent critics have been scouring the text for evidence that the country’s Islamist movements are preparing to create a morality police or that the legal age of marriage is about to be lowered to 9.  Many of these accusations are either baseless or merely leftover provisions from the 1971 constitution and were never applied in any meaningful sense, which will likely to continue being the case under the new constitution.  The reality is that, when measured against Egyptian constitutional tradition, the new text brings a number of improvements to the protection of certain rights and to the system of government and is not the catastrophe that many have been so determined to identify.

However, if the measure is changed, there are perfectly valid reasons to be opposed to the new constitution.  For example, considering recent developments internationally in the field of constitutional law, particularly in many African and Latin American countries, or considering even the aspirations that were expressed through the Egyptian revolution, the text leaves the reader disappointed.

Apart from the fact that much of the drafting is vague, a number of important rights are also lacking, which has driven many activists to ardently oppose the text.  It also does not present a convincing vision in many areas, including decentralization, the role of independent agencies and civil/military relations.

The purpose of this contribution is to discuss some of the new constitution’s most salient features, including the system of government, the role of religion, the protection that the text affords to certain rights, civil/military relations and decentralization.  Firstly however, the drafting process itself is deserving of some discussion considering the impact that it has had on the manner in which the text is being perceived in the country.

Read Entire Article

The Thinking Conservative
The Thinking Conservativehttps://www.thethinkingconservative.com/
The goal of THE THINKING CONSERVATIVE is to help us educate ourselves on conservative topics of importance to our freedom and our pursuit of happiness. We do this by sharing conservative opinions on all kinds of subjects, from all types of people, and all kinds of media, in a way that will challenge our perceptions and help us to make educated choices.

Columns

How could a British Canadian union solve the America Canada problem?

Combining the UK and Canada economy would revitalize both nations and their military ends any worry about Canada being a weak link in the free world.

Logan Act Violations Need Prosecution

Former members of Obama admin, Blinken, Nuland, Rice, and Vindman allegedly advised Zelenskyy to reject Trump’s peace and minerals deal in violation of Logan Act.

Pronoun Problems

Trump's campaign to restore common sense resulted in his2025 victory. His win was a death blow to the gender-bending pronoun pandemonium gripping the nation.

Movie Review: The Firing Squad

Although reviewers overuse the term “powerful”, attributing it to just about every film, The Firing Squad (2024) is truly powerful. It will pull at your heart.

Influencer Nick Sortor Catches Rep. Eric Swalwell Drunk!

Eric Swalwell PANICS when Nick Sortor asks about his Chinese spy girlfriend Fang Fang, and whether that’s a bigger national security threat than Elon Musk.

News

BlackRock to Buy Panama Canal Ports from Hong Kong Firm

A BlackRock-led consortium has reached an agreement to acquire two critical port operations in the Panama Canal from Hong Kong-based CK Hutchison Holdings Ltd.

CPAC, Other Conferences Reveal Conservative Landscape on Russia, Ukraine

Under Trump the US is refocusing on the Western Hemisphere, where more of its core interests lie and “America, it’s not [the] global policeman anymore.

Head of FBI New York Field Office Ordered to Retire Amid DOJ Probes

James Dennehy, head of FBI’s New York Field Office, reportedly emailed staff members to announce he has been asked to turn in his retirement papers.

Pentagon Announces $80 Million in Savings From First DOGE Review

Department of Defense has identified more than $80 million in wasteful spending through Musk and his DOGE team. It include DEI and climate change programs.

Trump Considers 5 Cryptocurrencies for New National Strategic Reserve

Trump has announced a plan to establish the first U.S. Strategic Cryptocurrency Reserve (SCR), sending prices for all five of his named digital assets surging.

Bondi Vows to Release ‘Everything’ Related to Epstein, Says She Was Misled

AG Bondi provided details on controversy around release of files related to Jeffrey Epstein, saying she was misled and vowed to release “everything”.

Former NIH Director Francis Collins Retires From Agency

Dr. Francis Collins, who led the National Institutes of Health (NIH) when the COVID-19 pandemic hit, has stepped down from the federal government.

RFK Jr. Says Texas Measles Outbreak ‘Top Priority’ at HHS, Sending Vaccine Doses

RFK Jr. said measles outbreak in western Texas that has infected more than 100 people and led to one death is a “top priority” and vaccines will be provided.
spot_img

Related Articles

Popular Categories

MAGA Business Central