Thrown To The Wind is The Film That Could Save an Entire Whale Species is Now Free to Watch

5Mind. The Meme Platform
Michael Shellenberger Substack Public Header

A month ago, Public released our first documentary, Thrown To The Wind, by journalist and filmmaker Jonah Markowitz. Thrown To The Wind reveals the reality behind the specious claims of an industry that has long billed itself as a boon to the natural environment. Our film exposes the price the world is actually paying for the industrialization of our oceans by offshore wind corporations: the killing of whales and the potential extinction of an entire cetacean species.

We founded Public to do precisely this kind of journalism: independent, uncompromising, evidence-based reporting that the mainstream media is too industry-captured and too ideologically blinkered to undertake. Those of you who are paying for Public make that possible. Without your support, we couldn’t do any of this.

Today, we’re releasing Thrown To The Wind widely, without the paywall. It’s imperative that this film reach as wide an audience as possible, to maximize its real-world impact. The survival of the North American Right Whale may depend on it.

While we want as many people as possible to watch our film, we owe a special thanks to those of you who pay for Public. Both filmmaking and investigative journalism are expensive. You’re what makes it possible. Thank you.

By Michael Shellenberger

Read Original Article on Public.Substack.com

Why This Documentary May Save The Whales

Filmmaker discovered high-decibel sonar levels while shooting “Thrown To The Wind,” about why the wind industry could make the North Atlantic Right Whales extinct

The increase in whale, dolphin, and other cetacean deaths off the East Coast of the United States since 2016 is not due to the construction of large industrial wind turbines, US government officials say. Their scientists have done the research, they say, to prove that whatever is killing the whales is completely unrelated to the wind industry. 

But now, a new documentary, “Thrown To The Wind,” by Director and Producer Jonah Markowitz, proves that the US government officials have been lying. The full film, which is at the bottom of this article, documents surprisingly loud, high-decibel sonar emitted by wind industry vessels when measured with state-of-the-art hydrophones. And it shows that the wind industry’s increased boat traffic is correlated directly with specific whale deaths.

The documentary may not stop the industrial wind projects from being built. After all, the wind projects were going forward despite urgent warnings from leading conservation groups and a top scientist at the National Oceanographic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA).

But “Thrown To The Wind” exposes the reality that the US government agencies, and the scientists who work for them, either haven’t done the basic mapping and acoustic research to back up their claims, have done the research badly, or found what we found, and are covering it up.

There appear to be at least two distinct mechanisms by which wind industry activities are killing whales. The first is through boat traffic in areas where there hasn’t historically been traffic. And the second is through high-decibel sonar mapping that can disorient whales, separate mothers from their calves, and send them into harm’s way, either into boat traffic or poorer feeding grounds.

Whatever the case, “Thrown To The Wind” blows the lid off a major scientific scandal and will have an exponentially larger effect than past warnings.

By Michael Shellenberger

Read Original Article on Public.Substack.com

Contact Your Elected Officials
Substack
Substackhttps://substack.com/
Substack believes that great writers, bloggers, thinkers, and creatives of every background should be able generate income from their audiences on their own terms.

Funding Dissent: Smash for Cash – A Breakdown of Manufactured Outrage in Modern America

Today a disturbing trend has emerged. Protests are no longer always organic expressions of public will, but staged performances.

 DOGE RIP: Full of Sound and Fury but Accomplishing Nothing

DOGE’s disbanding is irrelevant; its wrecking-ball reform approach failed. It should have learned from Clinton’s Reinventing Government and worked with Congress.

The Dismal Failure of Multiple Choice Testing

Multiple-choice tests undermine true mastery; real competence is proven through written problem-solving, not guessing, leading to flawed student assessment.

Is Actor Tom Hanks In Trouble?

For years rumors of actor Tom Hank visiting Epstein’s tropical Little Saint James Island were sex acts with minor children allegedly took place.

It Is Not Affordable To Vote Democrat

Democrats caused the affordability crisis, despite media claims it helps them. President Trump is working to fix the problems voters face.

Abbott Backs TPUSA Expansion Into Texas High Schools

Texas Gov. Greg Abbott backs TPUSA’s plan to expand its Club America student groups into more Texas high schools in the coming years.

Federal Student Loan Applicants to Be Warned About Colleges With Low Graduate Earnings

The FAFSA process now informs applicants of their post-graduation earning potential based on data from colleges and universities.

Bessent Divests From Soybean Farms, Says Farmers Needs Federal Aid Despite China Deal

Bessent said he sold his soybean farms and noted that, despite China’s pledge to buy more U.S. crops, American farmers still rely on federal support.

Kennedy Center Honors Raises Record-Breaking $23 Million: Grenell

The Kennedy Center Honors has raised a record $23 million for its annual award ceremony hosted by President Donald Trump in Washington on Dec. 7, 2025.

Trump Announces $12 Billion Farm Aid Program

Trump made the announcement at a roundtable at the White House to discuss his economic aid package for American farmers.

Alina Habba Resigns as Acting US Attorney for New Jersey

Acting U.S. Attorney Alina Habba resigned Monday after a federal appeals court ruled she had been serving in the position unlawfully.

No Restrictions on How ‘Trump Accounts’ Can Be Used: Bessent

Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent said in an interview that “Trump Accounts” established by the administration can be used for any purpose.

Federal Government to Announce $12 Billion Farm Aid Program

President Trump plans to announce on Dec. 8 a $12 billion economic assistance package for farmers, according to a White House official.
spot_img

Related Articles